Posted on November 20 2026
The best gifts for men between $100 and $300 are pieces he will wear every week: a good quarter-zip, a soft weekend sweatshirt, a long-sleeve polo, or a leather sneaker. Buy in a colour he already wears, check his current size before you shop, and skip anything that needs a tailor to fit.
Why clothing makes a better gift than gadgets in this range
Between $100 and $300 you can buy the best version of something he already reaches for, which is the kind of gift that gets used rather than stored. Most men will not spend $275 on a sweater for themselves, but they will wear one you bought them three times a week until March.
The trick is to stay in categories with low fit risk. Knits, polos and sweatshirts are forgiving; suits, dress trousers and dress shirts are not. If your budget is lower, our list of gifts for men under $100 that are not filler covers socks, wallets and other smaller pieces.
For the man who wears a sweater to work: a Bugatchi quarter-zip
A quarter-zip goes over a dress shirt at the office and over a tee on Saturday, so it gets worn twice as often as a crew neck. The Bugatchi Quarter-Zip Knit in Navy ($275) has a mock neck, a front panel of 60% cotton, 38% polyester and 2% spandex for stretch, and 100% cotton back and sleeves. Navy is the safest colour you can give a man; it goes with everything he already owns.
For the weekend man: a Psycho Bunny sweatshirt
If his weekends are hockey rinks, errands and the couch, give him a sweatshirt that is a clear step up from the one he has. Two choices, depending on how he likes things to fit:
- The Psycho Bunny Gabe Quarter-Zip Sweatshirt in Ecru ($190) is 100% cotton French terry in a relaxed fit, with a funnel neck, dropped shoulders and a vented hem. For the man who likes room.
- The Psycho Bunny Marc Quarter-Zip Sweatshirt in Heather Stone ($178) is a textured stretch blend of 69% cotton, 26% polyester and 5% elastane in a regular fit. Neater and closer to the body.
For the man who lives in polos: a long-sleeve polo
A long-sleeve polo is what most men wish they had in November: the collar of a shirt with the comfort of a knit. The Psycho Bunny Classic Long-Sleeve Pique Polo in Black ($138) is 100% Pima cotton pique and the easiest gift on this list to get right.
For a dressier version, the Blue Industry Hayes Polo in Navy ($275) is a Tencel, nylon, cotton and silk blend with buttoned sleeves and an arm patch, in a slim fit that runs true to size. It is dry clean only, so give it to the man who goes out to dinner, not the one who goes to the garage.
Slightly over budget: a leather sneaker
The Johnston & Murphy Luther Lace to Lace in Taupe Italian Nappa ($318) is $18 past the line, and worth it if he already wears Johnston & Murphy. It has a soft nappa upper, a leather lining, a removable molded footbed and a rubber outsole. Taupe goes with jeans, chinos and grey trousers. Only buy shoes if you know his size in the brand; otherwise, give a note and bring him in.
How do you buy the right size as a gift?
Check the tag on the sweater or polo he wears most, and buy that size. If the tag is gone, lay his favourite sweater flat and measure across the chest from armpit to armpit, then call us at 905-489-0809 and we will compare it to the piece you are looking at. Remember the fits differ: the Gabe is relaxed, the Marc is regular, and the Hayes is slim, so a man between sizes is usually happier in the larger size of a slim fit and his usual size in a relaxed one. Our Psycho Bunny sizing post has more detail on that brand.
Common questions
What is a good gift for a man who has everything?
A better version of something he wears constantly. A man with five sweaters still wears one of them most; replace that one with something nicer.
What colour should I choose?
Navy, black or a soft neutral like ecru or stone. Look at what he already wears and stay inside that palette.
When should I order to have it in time for the holidays?
Order in November to leave plenty of room for shipping, and earlier for the US, where duties may apply on imported brands.
Can someone help me choose by phone?
Yes. Call 905-489-0809 during store hours, Monday to Friday 10 to 5 and Saturday 10 to 4, and we will help with sizes and colours.
Where to find it
Every gift above is on our site. Order online, or come see us at 166 Bullock Drive in Markham, where we can help you pick a size in person. Shipping is free over $75 across Canada and the US, which covers every item on this list.